The companies argued that the case was "a rerun" of the antitrust suit filed against the industry in 2018, and that they simply watch each other "like hawks" in a competitive market. The judge rejected that, writing that the allegations are "more akin to hawks flying in formation — an activity that hawks ordinarily do not do."
The plaintiffs, 17 individuals and small businesses, allege four parallel moves that cut supply and led to the shortage, in which prices jumped by up to 500% in a year. They point to simultaneous production cuts from October 2022 to April 2023, a coordinated pivot to HBM, DDR4 wind-down announcements within three months, refusals to sign long-term contracts and Micron's shutdown of its Crucial brand.
The companies say these were independent business decisions in a concentrated market reacting to the same pressures. The ruling is not a judgment: the defendants have until 7 December to respond to the complaint, and a case management conference is set for January 2027.